Is Commodity Trading Profitable or Risky? We Investigate!

The world of commodity trading can be both challenging and profitable for retail investors.

This article, based on several academic sources, explains the risks of commodity trading and its potential profitability.

Should independent investors trade commodities, and what are the risks? We perform deep research into the truth behind commodity trading.

What are commodities?

Commodities are tangible goods such as food, metals, and energy that traders can buy or sell in the financial markets. These commodities are traded on global exchanges, and their prices fluctuate based on supply and demand.

Commodities were traditionally physical goods or raw materials such as sugar, maize, barley, pork bellies, milk, cocoa, cotton, gold, silver, or copper. However, the commodities exchanges have expanded to encompass more modern items such as energy and computer RAM chips.

Types of Commodities

Commodities are divided into four main categories: energy, metals, meat and livestock, and agricultural products. Some of the most popular commodities to trade include crude oil, natural gas, gold, silver, copper, wheat, corn, pork bellies, coffee beans, and cocoa. Trading these commodities can be lucrative for investors to diversify their portfolios.

Understanding Commodity Trading

When trading commodities, traders can use derivatives such as futures and options contracts to speculate on the direction of a commodity’s price. These instruments are used by investors to hedge against price fluctuations, allowing them to manage their risk exposure.

Investors can also trade commodities through exchange-traded funds (ETFs). These funds track the performance of an underlying commodity or basket of commodities, providing investors with exposure to the markets without owning the underlying asset.

Finally, it is important to remember that commodities are traded in the futures market, which involves a contract between the buyer and seller. In this type of transaction, the seller agrees to provide a certain amount of a commodity at an agreed-upon price by a set date in exchange for payment from the buyer. This type of contract helps to reduce risk since the investor knows ahead of time exactly how much they will pay and what they will receive in return.

How to Start Trading Commodities

To get started in commodity trading, you must open an account with a broker. Before selecting a broker, compare each provider’s fees and services, such as account minimums, commission rates, margin rates, and available markets.

Start Trading Futures, Stock & Currencies with TradingView

Next, select the markets you want to trade in. Commodity trading mainly involves agricultural products and metals. Each market has its risk-related dynamics, so it is important to understand them before investing your capital. Some brokers also offer educational resources to help understand different markets and their associated risks.

Once you’ve determined the markets you want to focus on, research each to develop an appropriate trading strategy that meets your risk appetite and investment goals. This may involve analyzing price trends, evaluating historical data, and news events related to the commodities being traded.

Finally, execute trades based on the strategy you developed while monitoring them regularly for any changes or potential losses.

Risks of Trading Commodities

Trading commodities can be risky, as prices for these goods are often volatile and subject to large fluctuations. One of the main risks in trading commodities is that they are heavily influenced by external forces such as climate, politics, and economic and market conditions. As commodities are physical assets, their prices can be strongly affected by the supply and demand in the market.

My thorough testing awarded TradingView a stellar 4.8 stars!

With powerful stock chart analysis, pattern recognition, screening, backtesting, and a 20+ million user community, it’s a game-changer for traders.

Whether you're trading in the US or internationally, TradingView is my top pick for its unmatched features and ease of use.

Explore TradingView – Your Gateway to Smarter Trading!

Commodity trading involves buying and selling commodities like gold, oil, or wheat. It can offer high returns but also comes with a particular set of risks ¹.

This means that if an investor is not careful and doesn’t monitor the markets closely, they could lose money due to sudden price fluctuations. Additionally, trading commodities carries more risks than stocks or other financial instruments since it involves higher leverage levels, increasing exposure to the underlying commodity.

It is important to note that trading commodities can be a profitable endeavor. Still, it requires an understanding of market conditions and the ability to take advantage of changing market dynamics. To minimize the risk associated with trading commodities, it’s essential to do thorough research and learn as much as possible about the markets before investing.

Research: The Risks Involved in Commodities

• Market Volatility: Commodities are subject to price fluctuations due to economic news, weather patterns, and political instability ².
• Leverage Risk: Investors often use leverage in commodity trading, magnifying profits and losses ³.
• Regulatory Risks: Changes in government policies can significantly impact the commodity markets ⁴.

Data: Profitability in Commodity Trading

Studies indicate that investing in commodities may infer the same risk as other investment avenues, but the potential for high returns is considerable ⁵. However, the days of making a profit of $100,000 in commodities trading are over ⁶.

Investor Behavior

Behavioral aspects also play a significant role in commodity markets. Risk-seeking behaviors of active individual investors often drive market fluctuations ⁷.

Advantages & Disadvantages of Commodities Trading

Commodities trading offers several advantages, such as leveraging investments, low spreads, increased liquidity, and access to various asset classes.

• Leverage allows traders to open bigger positions using less capital, leading to larger profits.
• Low spreads reduce the cost of entry and exit for trades, while liquidity ensures you can enter or exit at an agreeable price when necessary.
• Accessing a wide range of asset classes means you can diversify your portfolio with commodities such as metals, energy, livestock, and agriculture.

On the downside, commodities trading does come with certain risks. Margin requirements can be high depending on the broker and asset class being traded and require additional capital or margin calls if prices move against a trader’s position.

Furthermore, price fluctuations driven by supply and demand can be difficult to predict, potentially leading to losses if not managed properly.

Explainer Video: How the Commodities Market Works

Strategies for Successful Commodity Trading

One of the most important strategies when trading commodities is diversification. This involves splitting your capital into different asset classes, which can help reduce overall risk if any assets experience a downturn. Likewise, it would be best to spread your trades across multiple commodities rather than focus on one or two specific commodities. This way, you can have exposure to more markets and take advantage of any price movements.

Another strategy for successful commodity trading is to look for market inefficiencies, such as when prices diverge from their expected value or supply and demand dynamics are out of balance. By identifying and acting on these scenarios quickly, traders can often capitalize on price discrepancies or opportunities presented by unexpected events such as global macroeconomic shifts or natural disasters. This type of trading requires knowledge and experience and careful monitoring of the markets so that traders can act swiftly when necessary.

Finally, traders should always ensure they understand a trade’s full scope before entering it by researching its past performance and fundamental drivers behind the commodity’s price movements. This allows them to better prepare themselves for potential risks and rewards associated with each trade.

Should beginner investors trade commodities?

No, beginners should approach trading commodities with caution and take the time to educate themselves on the markets before considering a position. Commodity markets are complex and volatile, so it is important to understand the fundamentals of how each market works and how macroeconomic events may affect prices.

Are Commodities like Sugar, Maize Barley, and Oil something for the Average Investor to Trade, or is there Too Much Risk Involved?

What is Commodities Spot Trading?

The participants in a commodities spot trade usually expect to receive immediate or near future delivery of the actual goods they have purchased. This is a way for the corn farmer to find a buyer for his corn on the open market. Because of the short delivery time, spot trading will usually occur in a wholesale market and allow the buyer to inspect the goods.

What are Commodities Forward Contracts?

A forward contract is an agreement to exchange goods at a specified time for a price agreed upon today. This protects the corn farmer from falling prices and the corn oil producer from rising prices. It minimizes the risk for both parties to do business.

What are Futures Contracts?

As discussed earlier in the futures section, commodities can be traded as futures contracts, meaning that the buyer and seller of the contract do not necessarily expect to receive delivery of the commodities they have purchased; they receive the cash equivalent.

In the U.S., the regulating body for the commodities exchanges is called the Commodities Futures Trading Commission.

Should I Invest In Commodities?

As a commodity investor, you need to understand that particular commodity’s supply and demand variables. For example, a farmer will have more insight into the fluctuations of sugar or wheat than you will see as an average investor. It may be worthwhile if you have a lot of specific industry insight.

FAQ

Sources

1. Futures trading and investor returns: An investigation of commodity market risk premiums
2. Can deep learning predict risky retail investors? A case study in financial risk behavior forecasting
3. Commodities Rising: The reality behind the hype and how to really profit in the commodities market.
4. Commodity trade and international risk sharing: How much do financial markets matter?
5. The Complete Guide to Investing in Commodity Trading and Futures: How to Earn High Rates of Returns Safely
6. Behavioral aspects of commodity markets

How to Trade Futures Using Commitment of Traders (COT) Report