Using Earnings Power Value: An Accurate Financial Metric

Earnings power value (EPV) is a crucial concept for investors looking to assess a company’s true worth.

☆ Research You Can Trust ☆

My analysis, research, and testing stems from 25 years of trading experience and my Certification with the International Federation of Technical Analysts.

It enables a deeper evaluation beyond just the surface metrics, helping investors understand how well a business can generate sustainable earnings in the future.

Earnings power value provides a clear measure of a company’s ability to generate profits over time. It looks at consistent income rather than temporary earnings spikes, giving a truer picture of a company’s performance.

Applying EPV helps in making sound investment choices and avoiding overvalued stocks.

Understanding Earnings Power Value

Earnings Power Value (EPV) evaluates a company’s ability to generate consistent profits. Key areas to understand include the method of calculating EPV, the role of adjusted earnings and normalized EBIT, and the significance of the cost of capital.

The Earnings Power Value formula, introduced by investor Bruce Greenwald, offers a practical approach compared to Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) models. By sidestepping speculative future growth assumptions, the seven-step EPV formula focuses on historical average earnings without factoring in future growth or growth cap expenses.

Earnings Power Value (EPV) Explained

Earnings Power Value is an analytical method for determining a company’s value based on its ability to generate profits over time. It focuses on sustainable profitability rather than short-term earnings spikes.

EPV is computed by taking the company’s normalized annual earnings and dividing them by the weighted average cost of capital (WACC). This formula helps investors see a business’s enduring earning power, set apart from volatile or non-recurring earnings.

Adjusted Earnings and Normalized EBIT

For a more accurate EPV calculation, one must consider adjusted earnings and normalized EBIT (Earnings Before Interest and Taxes). Adjusted earnings remove non-recurring items like one-time losses or gains, which may distort true financial performance.

Normalized EBIT is adjusted to reflect what the company would earn in a typical year without extraordinary items. This normalization process ensures the earnings represent a steady state, making it easier to predict future performance. This method offers a realistic view of earnings power, aiding in better valuation.

Role of the Cost of Capital

The cost of capital plays a vital role in determining EPV. It represents the return rate required by investors to compensate for the risk of investing in the company. The most commonly used measure is the Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC), which proportionally combines the cost of equity and the cost of debt.

WACC is essential because it serves as a discount rate in the EPV formula, reflecting the minimum acceptable return by investors. A lower WACC indicates less risk and can increase the EPV, while a higher WACC suggests more risk and reduces the EPV. Understanding the cost of capital helps investors evaluate whether a company can generate returns that meet or exceed expectations.

EPV Calculations Automated

The EPV calculation is complex to calculate manually. Fortunately, Stock Rover simplifies financial analysis and calculates  EPV automatically.

In addition to calculating EPV, Stock Rover also provides other essential fundamental data for investors, such as P/E ratios, dividend yield, and financial strength metrics. This comprehensive approach allows investors to make well-informed decisions when evaluating a company’s attractiveness as an investment opportunity.

Try Powerful Financial Analysis & Research with Stock Rover

Calculating EPV

Calculating Earnings Power Value (EPV) involves a specific formula and considers various factors, including taxes and the sustainability of current earnings. It’s crucial to get these details right for an accurate valuation.

EPV Formula and Components

The EPV formula helps assess a company’s ability to generate consistent profits. To calculate EPV, one must use the formula:

 EPV = Earnings / WACC

Earnings—This component refers to a company’s earnings in the most recent year and reflects the net income or profit generated by the company. It can also be calculated as earnings before interest and taxes (EBIT) minus any preferred dividends.

WACC—The Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC) is a crucial factor in determining EPV. It considers the cost of equity and debt for a company, taking into account their relative proportions.

For example, if a company has 80% of its capital from equity and 20% from debt, then the WACC will be a weighted average of these two components.

The weightage given to each component is calculated like this:

• Weight of Equity = (Market Value of Equity / Total Market Value) * 100
• Weight of Debt = (Market Value of Debt / Total Market Value) * 100

Once the weights are determined, they are multiplied by the respective costs. The cost of equity can be calculated using the Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM), while the cost of debt is usually the interest rate paid on the company’s outstanding debt.

Terminal Value—Terminal Value refers to a company’s estimated value at a future point in time. It takes into account factors such as future growth rates and potential cash flows that may occur after a projected period.

Discount Rate—The discount rate is used to account for the time value of money and risk associated with investing.

Adjusted Earnings: Start with net income, then adjust for non-recurring items. This assures the earnings reflect normal operations.

Cost of Capital: This is the required return rate for investors. It’s a weighted average of the cost of equity and debt.

Components to focus on:

• Net Income: Core earnings from operations.
• Adjustments: Remove one-time gains or losses.
• Cost of Capital: Factor in both equity and debt costs.

These steps ensure the EPV reflects the company’s real earning potential.

Tax Considerations in EPV

Taxes play a vital role in calculating EPV. Start with pre-tax earnings and then apply the effective tax rate. This yields the after-tax earnings, a critical component of EPV.

Consider using the effective tax rate rather than the statutory rate. The effective tax rate gives a realistic picture of taxes paid and varies yearly.

Adjust for this benefit for companies with tax loss carryforwards. Subtract the value of deferred tax assets from the adjusted earnings. This adjustment ensures EPV reflects the true tax burden.

Being diligent with tax considerations ensures the EPV is accurate and reflective of the actual situation.

Sustainability of Current Earnings

Assessing the sustainability of current earnings is crucial. Look at the company’s historical earnings to determine if current profits are sustainable over the long term.

Stable Earnings: Companies with stable and predictable earnings suggest a sustainable EPV.

Growth Prospects: For zero growth in EPV, assume future earnings will remain at current levels. This method works best for mature, stable companies.

Market Position: Consider the competitive landscape. A strong market position indicates stable future earnings, which is essential for EPV.

Reviewing these factors ensures that the EPV reflects the company’s ability to maintain its current profit levels over time.

A Practical Example of Using EPV In Investing

Let’s assume we have two companies, Company A and Company B, both operating in the same industry. Here are the details:

Company A:

• Earnings Before Interest and Taxes (EBIT): $50 million
• Tax Rate: 30%
• Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC): 8%

Company B:

• Earnings Before Interest and Taxes (EBIT): $80 million
• Tax Rate: 25%
• Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC): 10%

Calculations:

1. Adjusted Earnings (Net Operating Profit After Taxes – NOPAT)
   • NOPAT = EBIT * (1 – Tax Rate)
2. Earnings Power Value (EPV)
   • EPV = NOPAT / WACC

Company A:

• NOPAT = $50 million * (1 – 0.30) = $50 million * 0.70 = $35 million
• EPV = $35 million / 0.08 = $437.5 million

Company B:

• NOPAT = $80 million * (1 – 0.25) = $80 million * 0.75 = $60 million
• EPV = $60 million / 0.10 = $600 million

Comparison Table

Metric	Company A	Company B
Earnings Before Interest and Taxes (EBIT)	$50 million	$80 million
Tax Rate	30%	25%
Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC)	8%	10%
Net Operating Profit After Taxes (NOPAT)	$35 million	$60 million
Earnings Power Value (EPV)	$437.5 million	$600 million

Comparison & Analysis:

• Earnings Before Interest and Taxes (EBIT): Company B has a higher EBIT ($80 million) compared to Company A ($50 million). This indicates that Company B is generating more operating income before taxes and interest.
• Tax Rate: Company A has a higher tax rate (30%) compared to Company B (25%). This affects the net operating profit after taxes (NOPAT), as a higher tax rate reduces the amount of earnings retained by the company.
• Net Operating Profit After Taxes (NOPAT): Company B has a higher NOPAT ($60 million) than Company A ($35 million). This is due to both higher EBIT and a lower tax rate for Company B.
• Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC): Company A has a lower WACC (8%) compared to Company B (10%). A lower WACC indicates that Company A has a lower cost of capital, which can be due to a better credit rating or more favorable financing conditions.
• Earnings Power Value (EPV): Company B has a higher EPV ($600 million) than Company A ($437.5 million). This suggests that Company B has a higher value based on its ability to generate future earnings. The higher EPV is driven by Company B’s higher NOPAT despite its higher WACC.

Example Conclusion

Company B appears to have a higher earnings power value compared to Company A, indicating that it is expected to generate more value from its future earnings. This higher EPV is primarily due to Company B’s higher EBIT and lower tax rate, even though it has a higher WACC. Investors might consider Company B to be a more valuable investment based on its earnings power. However, it is essential to consider other factors, such as growth prospects, industry conditions, and risk factors, when making investment decisions.

Applications and Implications of EPV

Earnings Power Value (EPV) is a key concept used to evaluate a company’s true value and is helpful in making informed investment decisions. By understanding stock value and determining overvaluation or undervaluation, investors can use EPV to guide their financial choices.

Assessing Stock Value with EPV

EPV is essential for assessing stock value. It calculates a company’s ability to generate earnings, excluding potential growth. This provides a baseline for investors to understand a company’s profitability without considering future expansions.

Using EPV, investors can compare stocks in stable industries where growth is minimal. Knowing the calculated values helps determine if a stock is priced fairly in the market. It also helps investors focus on companies that exhibit consistent earnings over time.

For example, companies with an EPV close to market value are likely priced accurately. But if there is a wide gap, it signals the need for deeper analysis.

EPV’s Indications of Overvaluation and Undervaluation

EPV serves as an indicator of overvaluation and undervaluation in the stock market. When a stock’s market price exceeds its EPV, the stock might be overvalued. This suggests the market expects higher future earnings growth than what the company can realistically achieve.

Conversely, if the stock’s market price is below its EPV, it indicates undervaluation. This scenario is favorable for investors looking for bargains, as it hints at the possibility of higher returns once the market corrects itself.

EPV also accounts for the business cycle, showing how well a company can sustain earnings during economic downturns. Understanding these signals aids investors in making strategic decisions, avoiding overpriced stocks, and seizing undervalued opportunities.

Pros & Cons of Using EPV

Earnings Power Value (EPV) offers a distinctive way to evaluate a firm’s potential by focusing on its earnings. Understanding both the strengths and limitations of EPV is crucial when comparing it to other valuation methods.

Comparing EPV to Other Valuation Methods

EPV provides a clear estimate based on a firm’s steady earnings and is unique in that it does not assume any growth. This makes EPV valuable for businesses with stable earnings and no expected growth.

Traditional metrics like the Price-to-Earnings (P/E) ratio and Price-to-Book (P/B) ratio can be influenced by market conditions, while EPV focuses on consistent profitability. This method can often avoid the market’s short-term volatility.

Unlike Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) analysis, which requires forecasting future growth and cash flows, EPV simplifies the process by using historical earnings. This helps analysts avoid complexities and uncertainties when predicting future performance.

Limitations and Critiques of EPV

EPV has limitations in that it does not account for future growth, which can be a significant flaw for high-growth companies. This makes it less suitable for young, fast-growing firms where future earnings are expected to rise significantly.

Another critique is the reliance on historical earnings, which may not reflect future economic conditions or changes in the business environment. Therefore, it may not provide the most accurate valuation in dynamic industries.

Additionally, EPV assumes that past earnings are sustainable, which isn’t always the case. Changes in industry trends, technology, or management strategies can render previous earnings less reliable for future performance. Thus, it’s crucial to consider these factors when using EPV.

FAQ